Welcome to P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant
P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant, located at 1747 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY, is a beloved neighborhood gem. With a rich history spanning over two decades, this classic pizzeria is celebrated for its authentically crafted pizzas featuring a perfectly crispy and chewy crust. Customers rave about the fresh ingredients, generous toppings, and the warm, old-school NYC ambiance. The menu has expanded to include delightful dinners, yet the pizza remains the star, consistently delivering delicious slices that keep patrons returning. Owner-operated and deeply rooted in the community, P & M is a must-visit for anyone craving true New York pizza perfection.
-
1747 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, United States1747 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, United States Hotline: +1 212-926-3155
P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant is a beloved staple nestled in the heart of Harlem, specifically located at 1747 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031. With a rich history spanning over two decades, this neighborhood gem has captivated local pizza enthusiasts and newcomers alike with its authentically crafted slices and welcoming ambiance. The phone number for inquiries and orders is +1 212-926-3155.
Stepping inside P & M is like taking a trip back in time. The charm lies not only in its vintage décor but also in the welcoming atmosphere reminiscent of classic New York pizzerias. Customers consistently rave about the crispy yet chewy crust, adorned with delightful bubbles that hint at the expert craftsmanship behind each pie. As one loyal patron noted, “Seriously good pizza, the crust alone deserves props,” echoing a sentiment shared by many.
Authenticity is at the heart of P & M’s culinary offerings. The pizza boasts an exquisite balance of flavors, with a delectable herbed marinara sauce and real mozzarella cheese that melt beautifully over every slice. Reviewers commend the generous toppings, particularly on favorites like the pepperoni pizza, noted for its “fresh hot deliciousness.” Additionally, the menu has expanded beyond pizza to include hearty dinners, such as BBQ chicken that has received high marks for quality and value.
What truly sets P & M apart is its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. The owner remains hands-on, often seen working diligently alongside staff to maintain the high standards that have endeared them to the community. Regulars and newcomers alike have shared heartfelt stories about their experiences, often highlighting the friendly staff who embody the spirit of hospitality that makes this place feel like home.
For those seeking a quintessential New York slice, P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant undeniably delivers. With consistently great quality, a nostalgic atmosphere, and prices that won't break the bank—typically around $2.50 per slice—it’s no wonder that this establishment has stood the test of time. As one frequent visitor aptly put it, “If you want a classic New York slice joint, this is it!”
In a city overflowing with dining options, P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant remains a cherished choice for both quality pizza and a taste of New York's rich culinary heritage. Whether it's a quick lunch stop or a late-night bite, this pizzeria continues to create memorable dining experiences for all who walk through its doors.
Seriously good pizza. The crust alone deserves props : crispy, slightly chewy yet tender, with those desirable little bubbles in the crust's rim that form when bread is well made. My veggie slice was filling and delicious and fresh, and the staff are kind. Great, old-school NYC pizzeria atmosphere. Does a busy red sauce lunch service.
Absolutely amazing pizza. Great tasting crust and truly authentic Italian style. I will definitely be ordering from here again.
Love their cheese pizza slices—consistently delicious. They are a lesser-known neighborhood staple. It’s older looking when you go in but the pizza is great and in my experience cooked to pretty much perfection. Slices are nicely sized and for about 2.50 you get a great slice.
What a big surprise to see the pizza shop still in business after 2 decades and the owner is STILL working his culinary magic . My crew I would frequent this spot when it first opened in 2001. It was our go btw to get a cost effective bite to eat to fill our bellies prior to drinking partying the night away listening to the cool chords at the St. Nick's Jazz Pub(gone 4evain the 2018 fire that took the life of a fireman ) Kindly note, the pizza is still the same, fresh hot Delicious!! The crunchy crust with the herbed marinara sauce and REAL mozzarella cheese, topped off with loads of pepperoni is . They've expanded their menu, with dinners,etc. I took home a 3 pc BBQ chicken dinner with a salad for 11 bucks. It was very good. The owner happened to be there and I was shocked and very pleased. Check out this neighborhood pizza joint. You will not be disappointed. After 21 years, he still smiles as he prepare service his customers.
I’ve been coming to this place for more than 10 years and the Pizza is still top notch top quality. It is friggin delicious. If you want a classic New York slice joint this is it!!!!
This is the place to go for an authentic classic nyc pizza, the best tasting pizza in this entire area.
This place is a Hidden Gem, amazing flavor, amazing pizza quality and competitive price, the quality of this pizzeria is undervalued, fresh products, crunchy and delicious pizzas, real Italian flavors for more than 25 years in the heart of Harlem, I recently discovered this local pizza shop and I can’t believe how good their pizzas are. This is so good that can be ADDICTIVE. Hardworking Italians with more than 59 years doing pizza.
Very nice and humble place in west Harlem. The pizza is very good and the stuff members are very kind. As a tourist from overseas the experience was very pleasant. I would recommend to eat here if you are nearby.